Jade Cargill Wins WWE Women’s Title But Faces Doubt Over Leadership & Readiness

The Breakthrough — and the Backlash

At Saturday Night’s Main Event on November 1, 2025, Jade Cargill captured the WWE Women’s Championship by defeating Tiffany Stratton in dominant fashion, marking her first major singles title in WWE. It seemed, for a moment, like her long-teased ascent had finally been validated.

Yet even in victory, questions linger. Experienced voices inside the wrestling world are issuing caveats about whether Cargill is truly ready to lead the women’s division as its top act. Her size and star power earn praise. Her experience, they argue, still needs time.

What the Critics Are Saying

• Veteran personality Konnan remarked: “She looks like a star but she’s not championship material yet. She needs to be able to lead people.” The comparison was made to how Liv Morgan’s first championship run was viewed.
• Commentary around Cargill’s heel turn and her in-ring storytelling suggests that while her physical presence is undeniable, the “top champion” role demands more than dominance—it demands consistency, charisma and leadership.
• Some fans and critics also note that while Cargill has held tag-team gold and made big appearances, the singles-champion workload is a different animal. The pace of main-event bouts, promo work, media responsibilities and character nuance combine for a heavier lift.

Why This Matters for WWE & for Cargill

For WWE

• Presenting a polished and credible Women’s Champion is essential: a top-tier titleholder becomes a focal point for bookings, merchandise, media, and pay-per-views. If the champion isn’t fully prepared in every facet, brand value suffers.
• The transition from tag-team standout to singles face of the division is delicate. WWE appears to be accelerating that path for Cargill—but critics argue it might be too soon.
• With Survivor Series and WrestleMania on the horizon, the timing of this title win is strategic—but also risky. Mistakes or lack of resonance now could hamper momentum.

For Jade Cargill

• Her win gives her the gold. That’s the key milestone every performer strives for. Now the challenge is how she carries it.
• The critiques provide a roadmap: polish in promos, consistency in matches, connecting emotionally with fans, leading the locker room (even behind the scenes) and handling media obligations.
• Because Cargill has a powerful physical package and mainstream appeal, failure to deliver could raise questions about ticketing her as the company’s “next big woman” and affect her long-term legacy.

What to Watch Going Forward

1. Title Defenses: Who she defends against, how she performs in those bouts, whether she picks up credible challengers and delivers compelling stories.
2. Promo & Media Work: How comfortable she appears in interviews, how she handles criticism, how she builds challenger narratives—it will show if she’s ready for the big stage.
3. Character Evolution: Will WWE lean into her dominant persona, refine her character depth, or pivot if fan reactions are tepid? The heel turn may open fresh opportunities.
4. Locker Room Role: As top champion, leadership is more than talking—it’s mentoring protégés, driving story-lines and being a consistent presence. Veteran critics say this is where she still needs work.
5. Fan & Sponsor Reception: Titles alone don’t guarantee resonance; ratings, social-media buzz, merchandise and brand deals will reflect whether Cargill’s reign becomes meaningful or merely symbolic.

Final Thought

Jade Cargill’s ascension to WWE Women’s Champion is a landmark moment—yet it’s just the start. The title is a tool, not a guarantee. If she wants to move from being “the big new star” to “the credible standard-bearer,” she’ll need to prove every night that she can carry the division, not just stand at the top of it. WWE has given her the opportunity; now the intensity, consistency and growth must follow.